Page 1 of 1

Question re AI(vibe) coding and a new engine

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 11:07 am
by Martin_au
First, huge thank you, Daniel (and all others involved) for CloudCompare. I've used it for so many projects over the years. It fills a huge void in the world of point cloud software.

If I were to vibe code a new app that swapped in a new engine for loading, data management and rendering, and ported over all the functions from CloudCompare, where would that fit? It will obviously be a nightmare from a code reviewing perspective, but at the same time, would resolve some of the issues acquired over CloudCompare's long heritage (large point clouds with panoramas being a good example). It would obviously have to follow all licensing requirements.

Could such a development live in CloudCompare's github on a branch as a great big contribution, or would you rather it stay out? As a more general discussion, where does AI coding fit into CloudCompare's current and future development processes?

Re: Question re AI(vibe) coding and a new engine

Posted: Thu Nov 12, 2026 6:39 pm
by daniel
Well, we do use AI development tools, but we try to maintain it under strict supervision. As AI can still hallucinate quite a lot, and tends to produce a lot of useless code. Still, these tools have been very helpful in the last months to improve some features like 3D display (clouds and meshes now display faster in the latest 2.14.beta version). And many improvements can still be made.

Anyway, you can of course try your luck with vibe coding. As long as the code remains open-source, I don't see any infringement of the GPL license. And I think it's preferable to have a separate repo referring to the official one.

Re: Question re AI(vibe) coding and a new engine

Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2026 12:16 am
by daria22
Good to hear the faster display in the 2.14 beta came partly out of that. Keeping every AI-written change under review seems like the only sane way on a codebase this size.

Re: Question re AI(vibe) coding and a new engine

Posted: Fri Nov 13, 2026 7:07 am
by Martin_au
Thanks Daniel. That sounds great.